Another GIK Start-up: 1 Million Shirts

Today a few of the people I follow on Twitter for insightful ideas about sustainable development (@penelopeinparis and @talesfromthhood) took over my feed with criticisms of a new project called “1 Million Shirts”. You can read about the organization at http://www.1millionshirts.org, and I’d encourage you to take a peek before reading through the rest of my comments on my take on the good and the bad of the organization.

For those of you who don’t have the time to browse the well-designed website, here’s the gist of things: Jason Sadler, who makes a living from wearing t-shirts for people and organizations, has decided to make the next step in the t-shirt world and try to do some good. He created 1 Million Shirts, has applied for 501c3 status, and has found partners at H.E.L.P. International (not to be confused with HELP International) to assist him in his mission: to collect one million t-shirts from all across America at his Loveland, Colorado home, and send them to Africa. Like many, I’m sure he’s seen photos of shirtless African kids who look like they could benefit from having a t-shirt, whether it be new or gently used, and his heart spoke to him and said, “Hey, I could help with that [perceived] problem.” To give the “official” reason for the one million shirts campaign:

“Poverty and disease tend to be commonplace in most African countries. Medical care is lacking, and food runs scarce. The rate at which disease transmission occurs affects the continent at an alarming rate. Since most people cannot afford suitable health care, they are forced to endure living below their means, which includes not having proper nourishment, susceptibility to disease, and deficiencies in combating everyday threats to one’s health.

1MillionShirts cannot solve all the problems that our African neighbors experience, but it can help to provide part of the solution.

The t-shirts provided by 1MillionShirts will give people part of what they need to survive. Your donation of 1 or several t-shirts will not only help people in poverty-stricken areas, but it will also help the environment!”

First, I’ll commend the guy for wanting to make a difference. As @IdealistNYC noted, “His heart is in the right place.”  But at this point, I’m definitely a bit skeptical of the whole plan. Some of the statements on the “Why” tab of the website make me doubtful about his expertise on the relationships between different arenas in development, especially the first statement: “Why not?” Well, my friend Jason, I can think of a myriad of reasons why to not send a mass quantity of a miscellaneous item to a developing nation, even if you think it could be helpful. Read the post on GIK (“gifts in kind”) here or in response to the rush to donate ‘stuff’ for the Haitians after the earthquake or this post on GIK from development logistics guru Michael Keizer at on the negative effects GIK can have.

Another statement that makes me skeptical, excerpted from “why” 1 Million Shirts was created:

“To produce ONE pound of new clothing, you would need approximately 723 gallons of water! Did you know that 1 in 8 people in the world do not have access to clean drinking water? Your donation of t-shirts will not only provide a means of clothing for developing countries, but it will also help to ensure the potential for more clean drinking water

I’m glad he put the word ‘potential’ in there, but until I see data showing me that by donating t-shirts to people who don’t already have them we will see an increase in the availability of clean drinking water, I’m going to remain skeptical of the direct relationship between these two variables (t-shirt donation and clean drinking water).”

I’m sure this same statement would be one of the organization’s arguments against purchasing new shirts made locally and distributing them. But would the potential good from that investment in the local economy, helping pay salaries for local workers through the purchase, outweigh the possible impact on local water availability? I’ll dig around and see if I can find some research on the impact of textile factories on availability of clean water in the surrounding area, but I’m a bit doubtful that the economic good coming out of the opening of those factories, especially in developing nations where sustainable job creation is one of many sound things that can contribute to alleviating poverty, is outweighed by the change in water availability.

I could go on with arbitrary criticisms of this organization, while trying to temper them with anecdotal and enthusiastic remarks about how great it is that there is a want to do good…but instead I’ll make a short hit list of my thoughts on the roses and thorns of this little brainchild:

The roses:

(a)    Yes, there are people in Africa (and in Washington DC, where I live) who need shirts. Whether they only have one or don’t have any, not everyone has clothes to protect them from the elements.

(b)   Jason has found partners in HELP International and a few other organizations to support him on the ground. This is more “could-be-good” depending on how HELP plans on assisting with distribution.

(c)    The website notes that they’ve thought about the effects giving out free shirts could have on vendors. And they’ve looked into the idea of providing allocations of shirts to women at no cost for them to sell, though there are a million unanswered questions in that (Business training for the women? Competing interests of children at home? Would there be a consistent supply of shirts, or would it be more like a bake sale — sell everything at once? Etc.). So this is like a ‘swiss cheese idea’ — it has some holes, but also has some valuable substance.

(d)   Sadly but truly, it’s more likely that people will engage with this idea, its catchy website, very readable blog, and feel-good message and spend the three dollars to mail a shirt to Colorado than the number of people who would put a three dollar check in an envelope, mail it to Jason, and let him pool all the funds to invest in something meaningful overseas.

The thorns:

(a)    There could be negative ramifications for local suppliers of t-shirts/clothing, who now have to compete with women who are being given the products for free. While some might call this “competition”, bringing down the price for all, I’m doubtful it will work that way given my own experiences in markets in rural Kenya.

(b)   The amazing amount of time, effort, and energy going into this project could be channeled into something with a more long-term, sustainable impact. Partnering with a selection of NGOs that make textiles, helping to fund them, and providing a more philanthropic capital model (as a random example), or even purchasing the shirts locally.

(c)    “Good intentions are not enough,” as Sandra S. has said repeatedly (she named her wonderful blog with that exact phrase). Partnering with a large organization for distribution is smart, but are a million t-shirts really what people living in poverty in Africa need right now? If you asked an African child on the street and asked what he needed, would a shirt be the first thing he said? Let’s think about the constituents/recipients here, and what they would say is important to them, not what we glean as being important from photos of topless children running around the bush.

(d)   It is entirely possible that if you add up the amount of money it will take to send and distribute the shirts throughout the countries named on the website, the sum will be daunting, could have a far greater impact invested elsewhere, and donations will not be enough to cover the cost of the shipping, leaving Jason sitting in his living room with 1 million t-shirts that he has to pay to ship himself to people who may or may not want them.

About these ads

19 thoughts on “Another GIK Start-up: 1 Million Shirts

  1. Good post and well rounded.

    One thing on the effects of giving out t-shirt for resell and/or bringing down overall price… First, if you flood the market with a free product, that same product sold at any price, even 1 penny, isn’t going to sell. Also, there is a marketplace of shirts already and if the new sellers (who got free t-shirts) under cut the current market place so low that the rest of the vendors can’t make money, what then. There’s no up side to this model.

    They need to just admit that they are destroying the entire clothing market by doing this. People will lose jobs, kids will go hungry (being extreme here, but possible), even though they have a brand new shirt on their backs. In the free market, this doesn’t just hurt one industry, it has a domino effect through the whole economy.

    I seriously might call this guy all the way from Kenya.

    904-312-2712

  2. This is a great post and I appreciate you taking the time to dig through the site.

    I might actually subscribe to your blog just for the “Roses/Thorns” section. It shows intelligence and I applaud you for not stooping to the level of others and saying offensive things about me. What’s the point of that anyway? To make them feel better about their inadequacies? That’s a whole other discussion…

    I’m doing more due diligence with our charitable partners who I engaged in discussions with for 6 months prior to launching 1MillionShirts. We spoke back and forth about some of the topics you bring up and I’m going to get more information for you. I’m not a professional Aid Worker, I’ve never run a NPO before, but I want to do something good for the world. That’s my goal.

    Whether it matters or not, the I do not live in Colorado, the shirts are being sent to a warehouse with donated space being operated by volunteers. I live in Jacksonville, Florida and will be visiting the warehouse often to help in any way possible.

  3. A well thought out, well-reasoned response.

    re: Jason Sadler – you have mentioned this issue of “offensive” comments a few times now (you also mentioned “ignorant” comments in your aid watch post). I have to say, having read most of the blog posts (and made a few comments myself on aidwatch) I have yet to see an “offensive” or “ignorant” comment. You seem to have (as alanna shiekh pointed out) a lot of anger about this – as she rightly said it’s Not personal. The point is the idea and whether the intended beneficiaries will, in fact, actually benefit or not – and to what degree etc.

    You say it yourself – you’re not an aid worker (or, it is assumed, a development academic, practitioner, policy wonk etc.) but surely you can recognise that the combined expertise of people that have spent years working in this field has value? Surely you can also see that people that work day in and day out with issues to do with development might be quite passionate about it. That is a Good thing, and as it should be.

    Development is a very broad area – and it is impossible to be on top of every single issue/debate for every country. I have a PhD in int dev – and specialise in governance/livelihoods – but having had to take a few years out for my young kids means that for the past year or so I’ve often been a step behind the latest research/policy/ideas. The point is even If you work in development, you can’t know it all – no one does. It’s a constantly evolving and very dynamic field – but you Can engage to the best of your ability. To that end, I don’t think you should (or Need to) get so angry with criticisms. Calling detractors “haters” is a bit junior school. If you put an angry video into cyber space, you can’t very well wonder why people are angry back. The criticisms are valid regardless of how it makes you feel.

    “I’ve never run a NPO before, but I want to do something good for the world. That’s my goal.” – so do a lot of people. The difference being they have put in the work (schooling, starting from the bottom and Learning etc) to be able to see where value really can be added or not.

    I always think this is good to remember –

    “At any rate it seems that I am wiser than he is to this small extent, that I do not think I know what I do not know.” ~ Socrates

  4. As a humanitarian logistics and operations professional, I have to warn you about the pitfalls of a project like the one million T-shirt initiative and urge you to read the book ‘The life of a T-shirt in the global economy’.

    Sending donations in kind to Africa through international transport systems is an idea that could have been supported in general aid and development ideas of the 90′s. But these days, support of local businesses, income generation schemes and micro credit are the way forward.

    Most of the collected T-shirts end up on the commercial market anyhow, even if you would have a good voucher-system in place to hand out the T-shirts – please do read about earlier initiatives.
    Why they end up on the local market? Because people don’t care for a free T-shirt, they care about a new roof sheet for their makeshift home or for a chicken to lay eggs. As such, quite some of your beneficiaries will sell their T-shirts, get what they actually need and in the process damage local businesses because the market is being flooded with T-shirts…

    Dennis Bours

    • Thanks for your comment Dennis – I agree entirely, especially after hearing a number of other logistics professionals weigh in. I wanted to present a balanced perspective in the post, but thought it was clear that I wouldn’t jump on the 1 Million Shirts bandwagon. There are a number of more sustainable and impactful ways any money spent could be used, and there are a number of problems with the mere arrival of the shirts in general.

    • Thank you Troy — I apologize for the mistaken reference to the wrong organization. I think there was some confusion across the board from what I’ve read related to the controversy over the 1 Million Shirts project. I’ll add a note to the post to clarify in case anyone else reads it.

  5. Pingback: boys t shirt

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s